NEWS TALK RADIO Our Hosts
Powered by: Townhall.com
Sign Up
Tuesday, November 03, 2009
Dennis Prager :: Townhall.com Columnist
A Society that Venerates Lawyers More than Doctors
by Dennis Prager
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
What grade would you give Barack Obama so far as President?




Those of us who are not true believers in expanded government are certain of the following:

If the 1,990-page House Health Care Bill becomes law, the average American will receive worse health care, American physicians will decline in status and income, American medical innovation will dramatically slow down and pharmaceutical discoveries will decline in number and quality. And, of course, the economy of the United States will deteriorate, perhaps permanently.

However, we are also certain that there is one American group that will thrive -- trial lawyers. The very existence of a 1,990-page law guarantees years of, if not more or less permanent, lawsuits. And the law actually specifies that states that do not limit attorneys' fees in cases of medical malpractice shall be financially rewarded. What we are seeing here, therefore, is something unprecedented in our history: Many trial lawyers will earn as much as most physicians, and fewer and fewer physicians will earn as much as successful trial lawyers.

Nothing better illustrates the reorientation -- indeed, the transformation -- of values that will take place if the Democrats' health care legislation is passed. Thanks to trial lawyer/Democratic influence, for decades, we have been moving in the direction of litigation-based society. But with a Democratic health care bill, the movement will accelerate exponentially.

Much of our money, our innovation, our creativity and our ingenuity will gravitate from medicine to law.

Young people who wish to make a good living -- and even talk themselves into believing that they are also doing good for society -- will opt for trial law over medicine. As far back as memory goes for living Americans, a young person who wished to do well, as well as do good in life, would likely choose medicine as a profession if he were bright enough and willing to put in the great number of hours necessary.

In the last generation, many of the brightest chose finance -- as it turned out, another often unproductive and often destructive arena -- to make a lot of money while believing that they, too, were doing a lot of good for society.

With the financial professions in trouble and in some disrepute, and medicine being financially and socially devalued -- doctors are increasingly called "health care providers" (along with nurses, physician's assistants, lab technicians, etc.; they're all the same) -- law, especially trial law, will be seen as offering the most opportunities for making a great deal of money.

No rational person argues that society doesn't need law or lawyers, or that all lawyers, even trial lawyers, do no good. That is certainly not what is being argued here.

But it does say something about a society when those who sue physicians and hospitals make as much or more money than those who heal disease. It says something about a society when it glorifies and rewards those who litigate while it demonizes and punishes those who produce the drugs and devices that keep its citizens alive and well.

This is part of the upside-down world the left is bequeathing to us and our children in the name of health care "reform."

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Dennis Prager is a radio show host, contributing columnist for Townhall.com, and author of 4 books including Happiness Is a Serious Problem: A Human Nature Repair Manual.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Dennis Prager's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Gen Y Word of the Week / Crockpot
"Robust"

as in robust public option
as in "john graham, mvp of the graham honeymoon –‘set my roster for total domination’ [caps for emphasis] THAT BUFFET IS PRETTY ROBUST!"
President Obama, even with his roster set for total domination, has seen his mandate turn into a man-date with Rahm Emanuel - but let's don't get talkin' about no jews no more.
Let's do talk about buffets. Who hasn't been to an all-you-can-eat buffet? Didja like the food there? Didja see more fat people than you knew were in the neighborhood? DIDJA LIKE THE FOOD THERE! (caps in lieu of you freaking moron)
The stupid vs. evil brigades march on. The stupidest put words in others’ mouths..."We are greater than this stupid notion that greed is wisdom." and cannot see the irony in their own: "If we want to keep our citizens insured" - Insurance - "A promise of compensation for specific potential future losses in exchange for a periodic payment -MONETIZATION? "Under proper medical supervision" and "help yourself to an autocratic country of your choice." - maybe it's just me, but one definition of autocratic, "offensively self-assured," fits Pres. Obama to a tee, and his entire notion that "here's what we gotta do: fix health care, energy, and education" is/was the Reddest of all "red herrings."
yes. one thing it did get right, this troll i quoted. i look at what i have right now, and i like it. don't want it transformed. don't want to be forced to buy something that someone insists is my right; don't want to forget that the personal injury attorney was once the dregs of his profession - an ambulance chaser; an expert in the MONETIZATION of the slip and fall. don't want to forget the last eleven words of the star spangled banner.
there's a ballgame you can take me out to!

one saturday rant, ranted..

1800 characters, with spaces.

One physician's opinion...
As a physician, I think it's ridiculous to think that society would take pity on the erosion of physician's income and status. Physicians still do well and few take pity on those that make more money than they do! The need for tort reform, in my opinion, is the elephant in the room. If, for example, the consequence of improperly fixing a washing machine was $10 million, then, would anyone be surprised if it cost more to fix washing machines? I get it, that people aren't washing machines but at some point, medical malpractice impacts on the cost of health care. Would I suggest that malpractice be eliminated? Grudgingly, no. Doctors are human and we also respond to both carrot and stick motivation. Malpractice awards on the order that made John Edwards famous are relatively rare, yet, they chill the medical infrastructure into maintaining war chests of malpractice insurance coverage. Inevitably, medical costs rise as a result. Society's focus should be on getting better and more available health care. If that means that doctors make less, well, OK, I'll take my lumps, but someone should point out that as much or more can be shaved off your future co-payment if effective tort reform were instituted. The malpractice industry shrouds itself in the image of being champions for the "little guy". I believe there is a sentiment out there among some, that finding yourself a victim of something "sue-able", is something like winning a sad lottery. For those who would hold out for the possibility of a "skies-the-limit" award, tort-reform would be decidedly unappealing. I would hope to appeal to those more practically-minded who can "connect the dots", that a ferocious malpractice environment greatly contributes to a high cost of health care. The fact that it has not gained attention under bright lights is puzzling to me. It is a ripe and justifiable target for criticism and call for reform
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Keep up-to-date with your local Dallas KSKY community.
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.